Archive

Thursday, 9 June 2011

Killing Climbing Asparagus

One of my Waiheke jobs is poisoning an infestation of Climbing Asparagus or Krulkransie (Asparagus scandens) on a private bush section. Asparagus scandens originally hails from the Western Cape of South Africa. In New Zealand it invades forest remnants and disturbed areas. A. scandens  chokes understory species, preventing their regeneration, and can ring-bark older trees. When the understory has gone and the larger trees eventually fall, it's curtains for the forest ecosystem as we recognise it.

A. scandens rampant in the understory of regenerating  native bush.
This invasive is shade tolerant and although it may not produce much of a seed bank, it compensates by producing seedling banks. Small plants may hang around for ages, inconspicuous on the forest floor until going berserk during their spring/winter rapid growth phases (though not as much as some other invasive vines). To top it all off, A. scandens is tuberous with 87-94 % of the biomass (by dry weight) of the plant occurring in the below ground organs (Timmins & Reid 2000). This plant is so successful at persisting and spreading that i doubt that even old-growth forest would offer much biotic resistance to its incursions.

The property is a large one and much of the work is done on slopes leading down to the coast so i use a 10 litre backpack sprayer. The poison of choice is Glyphosate (N-(phosphonomethyl)glycine) originally (before the patent expired) marketed solely as Roundup by its developer - that gargantuan fuck-up of a corporate citizen, Monsanto. 

Shaded area indicates the size of the property where i spray Asparagus scandens. A. scandens has spread throughout much of the understory.

For most of us mammals, sensitive individuals notwithstanding, Glyphosate is a comparatively harmless herbicide with an acute mammalian toxicity sufficiently low that table salt (sodium chloride) has a lower LD50. For those who don't know, LD50 is the median lethal dose in mg/kg (or (micrograms) µg/kg or (nanograms) ng/kg depending on the lethality) required to kill 50% of a tested population, so a lower LD50 means higher toxicity. Table salt has an LD50 of  3000mg/kg when orally introduced to rats whereas Glyphosate has an LD50 of ~ 5000mg/kg.

For comparison here are a few other LD50's,  all are based on oral introduction to rats unless otherwise stated: caffeine, 192 mg/kg; nicotine 50 mg/kg; ricin 22 µg/kg (note: micrograms, but intravenous); dioxin 20 µg/kg (note: micrograms); lectin bearing sap from some Adenia species < 2 µg/kg (this maybe recorded toxicity to individuals, not an LD50). The toxic action of lectins is similar to that of ricin and is a fascinating tale in itself.

Very few chronic effects of Glyphosate have been observed - it's (so probable in practice definitely) non-carcinogenic, non-immunotoxic, non-neurotoxic. As far as endocrine disruption is concerned most studies say no, a few studies say maybe, in high doses. Given the findings of one reasonably tight looking bit of research (Gasniera et al. 2009) it may be more about the formulation of a spray than Glyphosate alone. Of course, there are trade-offs; Glyphosate does persist in the environment as a pollutant, though largely inaccessible to anything due to its aggressive binding to soil. Reservations about very large scale agriculture use over long periods of time may be warranted - if not for their toxic effects on most of us, for problems with degradation of soil quality. However, in some circumstances, given certain temporal scales, this may still be the lesser of a range of possible evils.

In the case of my climbing asparagus control efforts spray is the only reasonable choice. Hand pulling, root digging, are energetically indefensible and pinetarsol isn't going to cut it. So what are some the trade-offs in my case. Well, Asparagus scandens doesn't have the good graces to grow in isolated patches. It's dispersed by birds who will often shit out the seeds beneath tree boughs where the invasive will germinate. This suits A. scandens just fine because as the name suggests, it climbs using established plants as scaffolding.

This means when i spray there are residual kills of understory native species. To begin with this used to distress me a lot. Though still cautious,  i'm now hardened. The goal is to preserve the ecosystem as a whole. Practical limitations on energy available for weed eradication mean attention to individual plants would be at odds with ecosystem survival. *Warning - Geek Alert* Coming in and spraying at this stage is the equivalent of casting an Armageddon spell at the end of a Heroes of MM battle you are otherwise going to lose.

 

The areas shown in the above video (sry about the quality) are of the easiest kind to spray. The Asparagus coverage is so thick almost no care is required at all. When i mention scaffolding survival in the video i mean surviving my spraying activities, not surviving the untreated Asparagus infestation itself - that's not on the cards for the unfortunate plants. What is more problematic/stressful are recently-invaded, dense groves of native saplings formed in light gaps. Here the weed is well established but is intertwined among the natives and has not yet over topped them. These areas are still to large for hand pulling to be energetically defensible and in any case there would be no way to get the roots and tubers out without killing the saplings. Here i have to work carefully to limit spray contact with as many natives as possible.

There is strong resistance on Waiheke to the use of human-synthesised chemical sprays. The local authorities use rancid coconut oil on grass verges and it works very well. However, the sustainability of this practice  - the where and how of production and the impacts on other peoples communities are important questions. I don't believe New Zealand has a thriving coconut oil industry.

My partner has recently begun work for a Waiheke based charitable trust doing weed eradication work. Some people take such exception to this weed trust's work that they target the work vehicle for sabotage. In the area i'm working there is a strong contingent of community chemophobes who fear poisoning from chemical inputs (human-synthesised or "unnatural" chemicals, i presume) and those who erroneously (perhaps) believe weed removal is resulting in an increase in slippage. It may be these folks who have engaged in such charming and potential lethal direct action as loosening of wheel-nuts.

Spraying is a choice, one that i am prepared to make in this circumstance. The consequences of not spraying would be to lose these forested areas with a great deal their constituent plant and animal biodiversity. If there are people in the community/stakeholders who feel so strongly that they will accept (or even welcome) those consequences, they need to be prepared for some tough conversations with people who share my response to the issue.

References

Gasniera C, Dumontb C, Benachoura N, Clair E, Chagnonb M, Séralini G. 2009. Glyphosate-based herbicides are toxic and endocrine disruptors in human cell lines. Toxicology 262  184–191.

Glyphosate Fact Sheet. http://environmental commons.org/glyphosate.pdf Accessed 10/06/2011.

Neurotoxicity, Immunotoxicity, and Endocrine Disruption with Specific Commentary on Glyphosate,
Triclopyr, and Hexazinone: Final Report.  http://gis.fs.fed.us/foresthealth/pesticide/pdfs/seratr01_43_08_04.pdf Accessed 10/06/2011.

Timmins S, Reid V. 2000. Climbing asparagus, Asparagus scandens Thunb.: a South
African in your forest patch. Austral Ecology  25 533–538

Monday, 30 May 2011

Science, language: A rant, a reverie. Part One.




*Warning! Rant follows. Hence much of the content is unabashedly subjective and probably ill-informed. Commentary welcome. Notification of shortcomings in argument welcome.*

The is the first part of a larger, largely unstructured rant whose components are only loosely connected, in that they highlight for me issues that arise from the actualisation/interface of the theory of the scientific method within/with cultural bodies/natural language (= scientific practice).  

First up: use of the term "Man" as an official scientific label for people/humankind.

David Attenborough informs us in his 1979 opus "Life on Earth" that using the term "Man" to describe people  is not sexist, it's merely the scientific word/term for our species. This assertion is false. The term scientific descriptor for our species takes the form of a Latin binomial (a two-part term), namely Homo sapiens. "Wise man" is an English translation of the binomial. 

A few opening remarks on taxonomic names.Taxonomic names exist as labels, attached to type specimens of the species they represent. This type specimen tucked away in a repository somewhere is the content of the label, not the meaning of the words themselves. In a strict sense they are *not* intended to function as descriptors. If my theoretical identification of, say, the African elephant as a distinct species had been accepted and i, being struck by a mixture of whimsy and reverence had named the species Aenigma darwinianus , that would become the scientific name for the African Elephant. It translates as (BIG assumption - my Latin is correct!) "Darwin's enigma. This doesn't tell me anything about the quality of the species/stuffed critter. The fact that some scientific names are comprised of words that translate as descriptors (explicit or metaphorical) is a mnemonic bonus for those striving to learn them, and may be personally satisfying as a point of style, if like me that's your bag. As with place names i personally like the label to have some descriptive relevance and get highly turned off by boffins aggrandising themselves or their mentors. 

Loxodonta africana, the African bush elephant (probably).
"African  oblique-sided  tooth" or "Oblique-sided tooth" 
for short are *not* scientific names for the species.
 Also important is that taxonomic names be unique (hence pan-cultural). Thanks to Linnaeus (the person who came up with the idea for the duel name system) and the cultural mores of his time, use of Latin is the convention for biological taxonomy.  Common or colloquial names are also useful for communication but lack the specificity required for a scientific discussion. Depending on the cultural or sub-cultural context (sometimes related to physical geography, but not necessarily so) a single common name can be used for a range of  distinct species or a single species can have a variety of different common names. Hence  "Man" is not the scientific descriptor for people/humankind anymore than "男子, człowiek or emberiség" are. These translations function as common names. Perhaps common names used within specific cultural contexts (as with "Man" in the western scientific community during a particular  period in time), but common names none the less. 



And that could pretty much put an end to it as far as i'm concerned. 

But wait.. there's more...

What may also be less apparent for those like myself not fluent or conversant in Latin, English and Mandarin, Czech or Polish and without access to a Mandarin-Latin, Latin-Mandarin dictionary, etc, is that the three words in the paragraph above are variously translations of the English words/concepts man, mankind and humankind, not the Latin word/concept Homo. To top it all off going back from "男子, człowiek or emberiség" to English may not produce the same words we started with. In translating them to Latin, Homo  may not be the first choice to represent any of them. 

There is a huge interpretive component to translation between natural languages, especially perhaps when dealing with rarely used and/or dead languages. How we translate words such as Homo with multiple nuances depends on context - in Roman/Latin discourse it may mean man (as in male human) *or* person - and involves choice which reflects our cultural preference. We chose to represent the contextualised meaning of Homo by the English word "Man" which speaks to the English speaking world's use of this word to represent all people (both sexes).

And still more...

Let's refer to the Label itself, then. I don't know if Linnaeus ever labeled taxa with latinised Classical Greek as some authors have, perhaps he was too much of a purest. But a derivative of the word άνθρωπος (anthropos) might have been a better choice (i.e. anthropology). Although it too was used to mean man as in "a male" this concept is more commonly referred to with ανήρ (aneer). άνθρωπος is more often used for labelling people overall. Maybe it was the same with Homo.

What this does highlights is the fact that Linnaeus, a member of a less-than female-positive, less-than egalitarian culture made a personal choice when he took it upon himself to label our species (this is complicated by the fact we don't (?) officially have a type specimen. Linnaeus himself has been designated, but i don't know if this is recognised as he isn't moldering away in a museum anywhere - so the label is content-less... but that's another tale). The words Homo sapiens cannot actually be found etched into our DNA anywhere. However, its useful for the purposes of rigorous discourse for our species to have a unique label and given that Latin is for all intents and purposes dead (= not strongly attached to concepts by most of the global populus), Homo sapiens currently seems like a relatively inoffensive choice. 

 How could you hate this fine (type?) specimen of Homo sapiens? Look at those eyes, Awwwww! It would be like kicking a chubby puppy! Carl Linnaeus in a 1775 portrait by Alexander Roslin (thanks wikipedia).
Finally, I wish to speak up for conservatism in this instance. The authority and therefore rules for naming species in biology are not akin to physical constants we observe in the universe, they are invented and championed by a bunch of folks who take it upon themselves to police such matters. We can change/defy/ignore these/their (i ain't on your committee - you dudes are Other) rules if we want. My questions however are as follows: Why would we want to? and What would the consequences be? Sure, with growing numbers of women in the scientific community, and (hopefully) growing public investment in the scientific method from all human cultures, we all might want some sort of say in what such an significant label should be - especially when it was bestowed by what today would be considered (probably) a racist, misogynistic male with the comparative social-political awareness of an Orangutan. Consensus would however quite likely be impossible  and not just in a global/spatial way. Consensus with those people who come after us would prove most problematic - we are hardly the paragon, the omega of human society and any label we chose may be offensive - or just down right silly - to a global culture-to-come. We could keep changing it up every so often but the system might become too unstable (if for Homo sapiens, why not for other taxa?) to be useful for the purpose it was created for and we would have communication=fail.